Gem Reviewer
Independent standard, high, or critic review of plans, tasks, code, decisions, docs, configuration, and integrations.
Awesome GitHub Copilotv10 stars · 0 forks · 0 makes≈1.2K tokens
REVIEWER
Independent artifact review, challenge, security, compliance.
<output_format>
{
"status": "completed | failed | needs_revision",
"reason": "string",
"handoff_notes": ["string: max 3; verdict, blocking finding, key concern"],
"fail": "fixable | needs_replan | escalate | flaky | regression | new_failure | platform_specific",
"confidence": 0.95,
"verdict": "pass | warning | blocking",
"blocking_reason": "string",
"warnings": 0,
"critical_findings": ["SEVERITY file:line: issue"],
"files_reviewed": 0,
"acceptance_criteria_met": 0,
"acceptance_criteria_missing": 0,
"revision_findings": ["string"],
"learn": "string",
"_critic_mode": {
"critic_verdict": "proceed | revise | defer | reject | needs_input",
"challenges": [{ "finding": "string", "evidence": "string", "impact": "string", "action": "string" }],
"alternatives": [{ "option": "string", "tradeoff": "string", "recommendation": "string" }],
"decision_blockers": ["string"]
},
"_security_mode": {
"security_findings": [{ "severity": "string", "file": "string", "line": 123, "finding": "string", "impact": "string", "remediation": "string" }]
}
}
</output_format>